Dr Osama Al-Azhari
Minister of Awqaf
(Charitable Endowments)
In this article, we are about to discuss the iconic debate that our Master ‘Abdullah ibn ‘Abbas engaged in with the Kharijites during the reign of Imam ‘Ali ibn Abi Talib (may Allah honour his face). The significance of this debate stems from the fact that we are fighting a fierce war against an extremist, unjust ideological system that assaults the sanctity of the noble Islamic law, people’s lives, and the security of the country and its citizens. Our invocation of this debate is attributed to the fact that Egypt has been in a direct clash with currents of political Islam, violence, Takfir (labelling someone as an apostate), and exclusion for nearly two centuries. Thus, confrontation requires courage, as extremist currents have practiced emotional and moral blackmail over the past decades, causing immense confusion and bewilderment across various social segments on both intellectual and mental levels. They persistently present themselves as the protectors of Shari’ah (Islamic legal theory) and its zealous defenders.
Extremist currents rely on thirty-five intellectual premises, including the persistent, diligent, and stubborn legitimisation of errors; these premises are found in the theories of Hasan al-Banna and Sayyid Qutb. Therefore, the debate is not merely a passing historical event, but rather the exact same recurring story with all its details and parties. It represents a struggle between a party entrusted with the religion and the legacies of prophethood, protecting its sanctuary and embodying the authentic understanding agreed upon by the masses of Muslim scholars of the essence and truth of this religion; and an opposing, deviant, Takfiri (based on labelling someone as an apostate), and aggressive understanding that attempts to steal credibility from this authentic understanding and falsely attribute itself to the Ever-Glorious Qur’an.
Abu Zumayl says: ‘Abdullah ibn ‘Abbas (may Allah Almighty be pleased with them both) told me: The Kharijites were formerly called the Haruriyyah because they barricaded themselves in a valley called the Valley of Harura’, hence the Kharijites were nicknamed the Haruriyyah for a period. According to some accounts, they numbered six thousand when they rebelled. Following Ibn ‘Abbas’ debate, twenty thousand of them returned (to the truth), and four thousand remained. This debate profoundly influenced everyone who was confused by the extremist ideology and had taken up arms.
The scholarly debate influenced many of them, distinguishing between those who were hesitant and possessed intellectual doubts, and those who were stubborn, arrogant, and insisted on bearing arms. Our Master ‘Abdullah ibn ‘Abbas took the initiative and presented his intellectual proposition, saying: “O Commander of the Faithful, delay the prayer so that I might speak to these people.” He presented this proposal to the trustee of this Ummah and the deputy of Prophet Muhammad’s (peace and blessings be upon him) presence, our Master ‘Ali ibn Abi Talib (may Allah Almighty honour his face). This serves as a directive for scholars to enter the battle competently and to distinguish truth from falsehood. This is precisely what religious institutions, with all their figures and bodies, should do: always take the proactive initiative in clarifying truth from falsehood, and right from wrong.
Our Master ‘Ali ibn Abi Talib was worried about our Master ‘Abdullah ibn ‘Abbas, because the extremism of these Kharijites had driven them to arrogance, pride, and harshness. The issue no longer allowed the mind the opportunity to think and discuss, even with an opponent; rather, it canceled out thought, intellect, and knowledge, allowing the ego to dominate with arrogance, pride, and contempt for the dissenter. For them, the issue was not one of thought, knowledge, argument, evidence, or proof, but rather a desperate insistence on rigidity and standing by this intellectual pattern that endows its bearer with arrogance. Therefore, when our Master ‘Abdullah ibn ‘Abbas entered upon them, they asked him: “What brings you, O Ibn ‘Abbas?”
Our Master ‘Abdullah ibn ‘Abbas knew them very well. He said: So, I dressed up, combed my hair, and went in to them in the middle of the day while they were eating.” He approached their leaders and thinkers, specifically targeting the spokesmen among them.
‘Abdullah ibn ‘Abbas was handsome and had a resonant voice. This procedure and preparation for engaging in a fierce intellectual debate is highly noteworthy: he did not prepare himself solely on an intellectual level, but also in terms of clothing and appearance. He stopped by his house and wore the finest garments he owned, entering upon them in the utmost beauty, splendor, perfection, modesty, and dignity, specifically to provoke their thoughts regarding the concept of beauty. When he entered, they asked him: “What are these garments you are wearing?” He replied: “Why are you criticising me for waring them? I have seen the Messenger of Allah (peace and blessings be upon him) wearing the best of garments, and Allah Almighty has said: “Say, ‘Who has prohibited the adornment of Allah, which He has brought out for His bondmen, and the good things of (His) providing?’” [Qur’an 7:32]. Here lies a decisive dividing line between us and the extremist currents from the MB to the Salafis (claimants of being followers of the early three Muslim generations) and Qutbis (adherents to Qutb’s thoughts), until the Day of Judgment which is their total neglect of this aspect. They completely ignore it because they believe it is not part of religion and that Allah does not look at our forms or bodies.
Ibn ‘Abbas commenced the debate by saying to them: “I have come to you from the Commander of the Faithful, the Muhajirun (Emigrants) and the ‘Ansar (Helpers). The Ever-Glorious Qur’an was revealed among them, and they are the most knowledgeable of people regarding its interpretation, yet there is not even one of them among you.” They did not comment on this point, so he addressed them: “I ask you a question: What is the reason for your hostility towards ‘Ali ibn Abi Talib?”
They replied that there were three reasons. He asked them: “Only these?” They said: “Yes.” He asked: “Is there a fourth reason?” They said: “No.” He then proposed: “Before I answer these three points and begin to refute them, if I bring you evidence from the Book of Allah and the Sunnah of His Messenger that refutes them, will you retract your stance?” They answered him: “Yes, we desire nothing but the truth.” Thus, our Master ‘Abdullah ibn ‘Abbas began to establish specific and disciplined guidelines with them, deliberately narrowing down the points of khilaf (disagreement) and defining maaal al-niza’ (the exact locus of the dispute). He did this to establish and lay down for those after him a system and a set of principles and foundations formulated by his enlightened mind that anyone confronting the ideology of the MB, ISIS, and Boko Haram can confidently utilise.







