By Ibrahim Negm
Since the Cairo Criminal Court listed the Council of European Muslims and 34 other entities as terrorist organisations, one objection keeps coming up.
Critics say the decision damages Egypt’s international standing and makes it look like a state at war with Islamic life in Europe. They point to angry comments from some European Muslims on social media as proof. It rests on three fallacies, and once they are taken apart, little of it is left.
The first fallacy is that the listed entities are “the Muslim presence” in Europe, so acting
against them means acting against Islam. This is exactly what the network wants people to believe.
As Asharq Al-Awsat reported, the decision does not target mosques as places of worship, the headscarf, Islamic schools, or any Muslim’s right to pray, fast and raise children in their faith.
It names a specific structure: a continental umbrella body, councils for fatwa, imams, family and youth, national branches, and 36 named individuals.
Europe’s millions of Muslims and thousands of mosques have nothing to do with this network. France’s own interior ministry report put the Brotherhood’s membership in the country at between 400 and 1,000 people, according to Le Monde. An organisation and a community differ in kind, not size.
The second fallacy is that Egypt stands alone.
The Cairo decision came one month after the European Parliament voted 381 to 167 for a resolution against Islamist entryism. It asks the EU to assess listing Brotherhood-linked entities as terrorist. In January, Washington designated the Egyptian, Jordanian and Lebanese chapters of the group. Jordan had already outlawed the Brotherhood and seized its assets. A French government report warned that the movement threatens national cohesion.
The third, and weakest, fallacy treats social media reactions as evidence. Comment threads are not opinion polls of communities numbering in the millions. The listed network also runs its own media outlets, platforms and youth forums, and knows how to mobilise its audience. When the loudest anger comes from circles close to the designated entities, it shows the decision has had an effect, not that it was wrong.
Many European Muslims have long resented this network’s monopoly over their representation and religious discourse. They rarely post, but they exist. The European Parliament explicitly called for support for Muslim representatives who defend democratic values and resist Islamist pressure. They have the most to gain when that monopoly is broken.
A state’s reputation depends on consistency and respect for the law, not on its adversaries’ approval. Egypt acted through a court ruling issued by a specialised circuit, in a numbered case, under Law No. 8 of 2015, for a fixed term of five years.
Egypt is also home to Al-Azhar and Dar al-Ifta. It is not hostile to Islam in Europe; it is one of Islam’s oldest centres of learning, and wants the faith presented there in its moderate form rather than its organisational one.
In the end, the decision does not damage Egypt’s reputation. It damages a story the network has long hidden behind: that criticising it means criticising Islam.Without that story, Europe’s Muslims stay as free in their faith as they always were, and only the organisation is held to account.
Ibrahim Negm
Senior Advisor to the Grand Mufti of Egypt








