The recent bombing of aid workers in Gaza has once again highlighted Israel’s lack of respect for humanitarian laws and its propensity for indiscriminate killings. This act of aggression not only endangers the lives of aid workers worldwide but also undermines efforts to provide assistance to those in desperate need. If Israel’s actions go unpunished, aid workers must brace themselves for further challenges in future conflict areas.
The tragic deaths of World Central Kitchen workers have dealt a severe blow to the United States and other countries’ efforts to establish a maritime corridor from Cyprus to northern Gaza, aiming to alleviate the dire conditions there. Furthermore, this incident has created a chilling effect on UN agencies and other aid groups, who have long struggled to navigate Gaza due to the Israeli military’s failure to grant permission or ensure safe passage. Israel has even restricted the delivery of aid to many parts of Gaza by barring the main UN agency, UNRWA, from making deliveries.
These acts of violence against aid workers are not isolated incidents. Rather, they represent a systematic campaign by Israel to undermine humanitarian agencies operating in Palestine. UNRWA, which provides aid and services to Palestinian refugees in Gaza and the surrounding region, has faced a crisis since Israel accused several of its staff members of involvement in Hamas attacks against Israel on October 7. These allegations prompted the United States, one of UNRWA’s largest donors, and others to suspend funding, placing the agency’s future in jeopardy.
Israel has failed to provide any evidence supporting its accusations against UNRWA staff members, as confirmed by the European Union’s top humanitarian aid officials who stressed the critical role of UNRWA in Gaza and called for its continued support. Additionally, the UN agency for Palestinian refugees has accused Israel of detaining and torturing its employees, coercing them into making false confessions about their alleged ties to Hamas.
This attack on the humanitarian convoy further underscores Israel’s indiscriminate use of force and disregard for civilian casualties in Gaza. While Israel claims to deploy sophisticated intelligence to target Hamas and other militants, it is evident that their indiscriminate killing attitude has resulted in the deaths of thousands of innocent women, children, and even Israeli hostages seeking assistance.
Israel has consistently maintained that no target is off-limits, even striking ambulances, vehicles carrying aid, relief organisation offices and UN shelters – often claiming the presence of armed fighters. Moreover, Israeli forces have demonstrated a willingness to inflict widespread destruction based on mere suspicion of militant presence or tactical considerations. Strikes on Palestinian homes, with families seeking shelter, occur on a near-daily basis, with no explanation of the intended target. Videos released by the military often depict the targeting of individuals without visible weapons, yet those targeted are labelled as militants.
For humanitarian workers, it’s imperative to guarantee their legal rights and protections under both international humanitarian law and domestic legislation. Those who commit acts of violence or harassment against humanitarian personnel must be held accountable for their actions. The United States, Britain, Poland, Australia, and Canada have all called on Israel to provide answers regarding these deaths. In response, Israeli Defense Minister Yoav Gallant has initiated an investigation and ordered the establishment of a joint situation room to facilitate co-ordination between the military and aid groups.
However, there remains a pressing question: Will the anger felt by Israel’s allies translate into meaningful pressure on the nation? If Israel is not held accountable for these crimes, the situation for humanitarian aid workers will become increasingly complex, not only in Gaza, where the spectre of famine looms, but also in other conflict zones. Such inaction sends a dangerous message that targeting aid workers carries no consequences.
